Relatives of fatal Berkel barn fire call for clarity: 'Lack of disclosure of suspects is unpalatable'

https://www.rijnmond.nl/nieuws/1873591/nabestaanden-fatale-schuurbrand-berkel-vragen-om-duidelijkheid-gebrek-aan-openheid-verdachten-is-onverteerbaar

It begins on April 28, 2024, with a barn fire on the Noordeindseweg in Berkel en Rodenrijs. Among the debris, the investigators find a drug lab. The next day it turns out to be even more serious: in a car in the barn lies a dead man. He died from the fire, but was it an accident, or arson? At the first hearing, the suspects don't want to say anything about it.

Sitting in the courtroom in Rotterdam are the relatives of the 20-year-old victim. Lawyer L'Homme articulates their feelings. "They are still in a heavy mourning process. We see no openness from the suspects, which is indigestible for them. They are left with this question: what exactly happened?"

The judge also appealed to the two men in the dock. "Did you see it yourself?" The 29-year-old defendant M.F. says, "I feel very sad for the family, but I have nothing to add." The 22-year-old Z.K. uses the same words. So no clarity on their part.

Flames erupted from the roof of the barn in Berkel en Rodenrijs.© Spa-Media

'Clumsy way'

According to the prosecution, it went as follows. In the barn on Noordeindseweg was a drug lab, where the two suspects and the later victim were working on April 28. They call a fourth person saying "Oh dear, there's a fire. This fourth man is also being held as a suspect.

The prosecution does not believe the fire was intentionally set, but it did occur "because these two people were acting in a clumsy manner." Cocaine and amphetamine were being prepared in the shed. Because the suspects made stupid mistakes, they are responsible for the fire and thus for the victim's death, the prosecution says.

Overdue maintenance

The men's two lawyers see it very differently. "The forensic report shows that there is no clear cause of the fire," they say. There are three options: an accident, a crime, or suicide. The latter option is causing slight stir among the bereaved families.

Attorney Altindag further fleshes out the variant "accident. The barn was adjacent to a residential house, which was also affected by the fire. In the residence was the brother of the owner of all the properties. Both brothers allegedly had a conflict over overdue maintenance.

Altindag: "There would have been a fire before, there was a report to the municipality. Maybe leakage was the cause of the fatal fire." The prosecutor says he has great difficulty with this scenario involving completely different people.

A white tent was placed near the barn where the body was found.© MediaTV

Unrest over drug labs

The lawyers are asking that their clients be released for the time being. According to them, there is no evidence that they are guilty of the fire, let alone the fatal consequences. The prosecution sees it differently. "Their involvement is indisputable," it said.

The prosecutor is referring to that other fatal case earlier this year, at the Schammenkamp in Rotterdam. There, an explosion in a drug lab killed three people. "There is enórm much unrest in society about the drug labs. The criminal world invades residential neighborhoods." According to the prosecution, the young victim was apprenticed to the suspects.

The fire in Berkel and Rodenrijs released a lot of smoke © MediaTV

Risks taken for granted

The judge cut the knot: both suspects remain in pretrial detention. "It's a horrible case. It's a difficult case. There are a lot of things we don't know yet. But right now we see enough evidence that you were involved in the arson, that you took risks for granted."

The next hearing is on Oct. 28. It is not yet clear whether it will be a substantive hearing then.

team
Kötter L'Homme Plasman Lawyers

  Here the highest
possible level of
  legal assistance
      pursued 

April 10, 2025
The arrest of Vito Shukrula, lawyer for Ridouan Taghi, has hit like a bomb with fellow criminal lawyers. Well-known criminal lawyer Peter Plasman has been equally "shocked and bewildered" by the news. ,,It is of course only a suspicion, but after all the commotion you may assume that the Public Prosecutor's Office (OM) will not act overnight. The OM will think they have a strong case. For now, I assume the prosecution has thought carefully about this arrest. Arresting a lawyer is a very heavy step.'' Plasman also cannot get over the fact that a lawyer seems to have once again functioned as an errand boy.
April 8, 2025
Will a pedometer provide a definitive answer to the death of 30-year-old Laura from Leiden? The Public Prosecutor's Office (OM) thinks so, but the lawyer of the victim's ex, Jordi L'Homme, expects nothing from it, it appeared Monday morning during the fifth preliminary hearing against suspect Paul V.
April 7, 2025
Let the Public Prosecutor's Office handle the lighter cases itself. Then judges can focus on the heavier cases so that there are enough cells for the convicts who really belong there, argues attorney Peter Plasman.

Contact form

Please fill in your details in the form below and we will contact you as soon as possible.

EN